Unfortunately never had a gf willing to try anal before, how does it compare to regular vag sex? Is it really better or just overrated?

Much tighter

Much, much tighter.
I fucking LOVE anal

+1

Love fucking a slut's ass....and it's all about my pleasure and not the whore slut's pleasure...

I have always been an affectionado of anal sex with woman and indulged with several girlfriends and my three wives. My last wife was great at anal and she could squeeze my cock at will with her muscles. I loved pussy too but if asked I preferred a woman's asshole every time. Even though it was messy at times.

The only girl that ever has had anal with/ for me is my current girl friend. She offered it and enjoys it. I love the tight softness. She enjoys it as much as vaginal sex. To me it is a much more intimate thing. I know now what I missed for lots of years

Fuck seems like I'm missing out lol.

The entrance is tighter, kind of like if you make an 'o' with your thumb and index finger, keep those tight and jerk off.

I think the pussy feel better if I girl know how to squeeze. The whole pussy make things tighter, not only the entrence and the ring muscle as with anal.

However, the whole feeling of sexiness when a women let you in thru the back door can make anal better, just for the taboo-factor alone.

Pussy is much better, but there is something so nasty about fucking ass that makes it good.

When I fuck a woman's arse it's more because I can rather than than I want to; if she gives up that hole to me then I know I'm shagging a dirty slut with few morals.

I prefer cunt then mouth and fucking her arse is my last choice but if it's on offer then I'll take the opportunity.

It's incredible if she is really into it and you use lots of lube. Don't even try if she isn't super horned up.

With a pussy, even a tight one you feel a fair grip around your shaft but it can slip and slide in and out no matter what. With anal I find trying to slowly pop your cock head into her tiny asshole is much slower and it really grips your helmet - almost as if it wants to push it out at first. However, since the muscle is much tighter it's like having someone hold a finger and thumbs really tightly around your helmet with lots of lube - you cum very quickly.

Plus the sight of her bouncy smooth arse and seeing her tits wobble around as she also cums super intensely and fast also turn you on wayyyy more.

A lot of girls don't try it because guys are super pushy and unlike vaginal you need to be really in the zone to do it (for her). My misses says it's the anticipation of pain that puts her off straight away, however if super horny and you take it slow it's like normal sex x10 - you both cum hard and no damage is done. Tbh, i hate to admit it but I prefer not having anal sex loads - it gets you super worked up for when you do know she willing to take it in the butt. It's her call at the end of the day - never pester a girl to do it as you'll likely have the opposite effect.

Very true!! I've never asked a girl or guy for anal. Always let them ask for it. Great advice!

Yeah good tip thanks!

Can I ask a serious question. How often does anal sex result in the smell of shit being impossible to ignore? And with that said how often if at all does shit make an actual appearance during anal sex? I'm not spoiling here, just curious as it's those things that have always put me off. I shouldn't imagine it always goes smoothly like in porn.

Its tight, its fun, but i think its as much mental as anything. You are dominating your partner when your cock is up their ass, no mistake. They're giving, you're taking.

Nothing beats the vagina, though. And if a woman keeps her muscles in shape there, the tightness arguement is out the window. Anyone who has been musclefucked by kiegels can testify.