Only tried anal a couple of times. Much tighter, but messier.

I much prefer a nice vagina. Tastes and smells so much better than a asshole...

I've been with girls that were really interested in it, but I always turned it down because I was a bit creeped out by the hygiene factor. As I got more comfortable with it, I also got together with my current gf, who had done it before and really gets off on anal play.

Since then, I've done it a few times, and each time I come away thinking, "Eh, that's not really worth it." It does feel super tight, which is nice, bit there's so much effort that goes into it. It requires a lot of lube, and a lot of prep working fingers and toys first to get things good and relaxed. Even then, I'm on the thick side, so it ends up causing pain unless I make slow shallow thrusts. I've come close to cumming from it, but I just end up getting worried about hurting her, so I can't enjoy it.

My wife enjoys it, so I like it simply because I love to see her cum that way. I also enjoy using toys/beads on her that way as well...she's got a very cute ass for a 46 year old!

Likewise

Much overrated, in my opinion. The anal sphincter is tight but, once past that, it's all much looser than a cunt. Even one that's had babies stretch it.

I've known women who liked anal, and have fucked their asses for them, but I've never enjoyed it anywhere near as much as vaginal or oral sex.

One place where it does have its place, though, is as a dominance tool. My wife likes to be dominated and used but doesn't like anal sex, so I fuck her in the ass sometimes to put her in her place and to make her feel used. Somehow, she manages to get something positive from it then.

Usually, for both, in my opinion, unless the one on the receiving end douches first. Even then there's no guarantee that their system won't pass more shit down the tube while you're fucking them.

Love ass fucking, hell, my Latina girlfriends took cock up their ass like drinking rum and even sucked my cock clean after shooting a load in ass.So no big deal seeing a bit of shit on my dick, remember, you are doing the 'nasty' sex.
When she say's it 'hurts' but has her hands spreading open her hole, fuck her blind.

for me vag is always the tops! wayyy better than anything else.

Unless she has taken a shit before and is generally clean your cock wont have shit on it - porn vids prove this, although those girls have likely used a douche to clean before going on camera.

my partner just has a bath before, makes sure she hasn't taken a dump that day, she is super mega turned on (its a lot of work; kissing, touching, building things slowly with fingers and toys) before even trying. at any moment the mood could be lost simply by using the wrong toy on her or we laugh, etc - its game over for anal sex.

some girls must like it a lot just like some guys do but i think for most its reserved for extremely rare moments. it just doesnt happen like porn. how often do you want to shove something up your bum? see what i mean...

i love pussy; clit, flaps, the hole, her wetness, the taste and smell; you can stretch it open gently without pain (just dont ram your whole hand in; youll be kicked in the balls if you do). a pussy is designed to have cocks stuffed in it and its amazing.

The older I got the more I wanted anal due to the kink factor and tighter hole and I could slam the hell out of her that way.

YOU ARE

If I could do anal w/ every sex partner I've ever fucked, do it in a second. Love anal with every cell in my body

Did anal on a woman once, hated it.