I would pick princess jasmine and fuck her as hard as I could to make it worth the awkwardness and try not to think about my girlfriend getting plowed

definitely the policewoman.

I'd pick Heroine - would fuck her so good and then have her titty fuck me to a cum splattering orgasm.

I choose Harry's Policewoman and suggest we go to the same room to swap girlfriends. I would bend that sexy little Policewoman over the bed, with her hands handcuffed behind her back. Holding onto the handcuffs as I fill her pussy with my cock. Cumming on her back and flipping her over onto the bed. Undoing her handcuffs and laying her flat on the bed, so I could get a good feel of those tits. Rubbing my cock between them as she licks the tip of my cock with each thrust. Positioning her so the two girls are next to each other, encouraging them to kiss as Harry and I fuck our partners for the night giving them both the ride of their life. To finally have us all cum simultaneously and collapse to the bed to rest up to switch partners and start again.

what i would do if I was you is, lay back on the couch and keep dreaming

Well that's no fun. What is jerking off without fantasy?

well the scrnario would ahve to eb rearranged abit for me, but I'd pick "the heroine" because I'd love to eat the pussy of any girl bold enough to dress up as Molatov Cocktease.

Lolz! Great answer, Candy.
If it were a date, I'd pick Jasmine, but I'm at the party to fuck so I'm going to go with Heroine and we're going to go to our own room and fuck each other up down and sideways. Then when I go home I'll listen to how my gf rode that beast of a cock to several orgasms, we'll make out, and I'll cum over her tits because she'll be too sore for sex so soon.

I'd pick no one. I'd want to jack off while watching my GF get worked over by the horse cock.

I'm with kamuishirou. I'd want to fuck side by side. Hearing my gf shriek with that horsecock in her would just make me harder than Superman on Viagra.

My husband and I actually went to a costume party similar to this. We went in with open minds, telling eachother no matter what happens we are only doing it for our pleasure and nothing else. My husband proposed that we be with whom ever we feel comfortable with, then I proposed we be with whom ever we want to see eachother with. So I picked out this really hot young girl, petite sexy body, perfect round boobs, long blond hair dressed as "Jeanie" from "I dream of Jeanie" 60's tv show. My husband picked out a tall handsome guy dressed as Tarzan wearing only a very small tight Tarzan style speedo, tanned hairless body. We ended up talking with them both and getting really comfortable the four of us. The girl dressed as Jeanie actually had a boyfriend who enjoined the idea of us all going into a small couples room together. The five of us ended up having alot of fun that night MfMfM action. The party was alot of fun. it was a swingers party invite only. couples n singles.

My husband says he'd defiantly fuck Harrys police woman. and as for myself after pleasuring that huge hung cock of Harry Id move on over to play with my husband and police woman ;P

Ive cum many times to this hot little fantasy post ty